Sunday, October 9, 2011

Response to Sharol


Week 2 Required Reading

Education can be humorous at times. The idea is very basic actually- to convey knowledge to another individual for them to use and retain. It's not the basic idea that is in question but the method however. Michelangelo states that within every block of marble or stone is a beautiful statue. Imagine if every teacher, parent, and school administrator shared this ideal with education. Maybe then we could get back to the basic idea and see why students may have "road blocks" in their learning. Rather than comparing them to student "a" from district "z". Students like most humans make snap judgments based off of assumptions we've created in our minds from previous experience or what we've been told. I wonder how can we get our students to buy in to their own intelligence without having to test them to death? Just wondering....

2 comments:

Fari Lopez said...
Sharol,
I can't agree with you more. I really don't like it when, after all our efforts through the whole school year, our students' performance is just reduced to DATA ( a word I am beginning to dislike). That seems to be all districts and principals worry about where I live. They want us to implement 21st century skills in our content, but they still agree to measure students with 20th century assessments. I am glad I quit working for the district and joined a charter school.
Fari
Kevin McLain said...
Sharol,

Like Fari said, "I can't agree with you more." I think what you are getting at is the idea of seeing a student as a unique individual with specific needs rather than a number on a standardized test. I used to be of the mindset that data was great because it provides us a way as educators to track our progress and see our improvement and what is the downside to that? Now I see that such thinking takes away seeing the whole person and reduces individuals to a set of numbers. Numbers that are invented standards that when applied to a child define and confine them to those expectations

Response to Lania Clark


I think this book can offer a lot of insight for those involved in the arts, in particular.  I can’t say that I mind that it was written by a conductor.   “Every problem, every dilemma, every dead end we find ourselves facing in life, only appears unsolvable inside a particular frame or point of view.” (Zander and Zander, 2000, p. 14)  When I read this portion, I couldn’t help but think of our elementary coordinator.  She’s a fantastic example to me.  Despite all of the challenges she faces on a daily basis, she approaches each “obstacle as an opportunity”.  I’ve seen her turn messy situations into positive outcomes for everyone involved.  

“What might I now invent,
That I haven’t yet invented,
That would give me other choices?” (Zander and Zander, 2000, p. 15)

I love this approach.  It is problem solving through innovation.  In my life, I find that I favor having an excess of choices. I am never more frustrated than when I feel I don’t have enough options.  (My husband on the other hand prefers 2 or 3 strong options so he can make a decisive choice and move on. Clearly we need each other to keep balance!)  But I’m diverging from the book - the point is, this approach to problem solving is an attempt to burst open the box.  It allows more solutions enter the scene. 

This book has some interesting perspectives on perception of reality.  I would agree to the truth that seeing things from another person’s point of view completely changes the relationship for the better.  Empathy allows us to step outside our own needs and desires to consider someone else’s.  At points, however, The Art of Possibility sounds a lot like the “Positivism” mantra that has become so popular.  Change your lens and you can change your life.  Well, that’s somewhat true…but it doesn’t negate the facts, or physically change circumstances.  I think you need to have a balance.  At times it is appropriate to accept a situation for what it is.  

Chapter 4 is an interesting conversation about human worth.  What makes us valuable as human beings?  The “Art of Possibility” speaks about declaring yourself a contribution, rather than assessing your worth based on tangible achievement.  I have to bring up my mother-in-law here…she was famous for reminding my husband: “You’re a human being, not a human do-ing!” as he grew up.  When you’re naturally a hard worker, you need to hear that every once in a while.  There’s a lot to be said for viewing yourself and others as acontribution.  I think it takes away some of the self-invented stress and pressure to succeed.  Each day we have the opportunity to contribute to someone else’s life, and to receive what they are able to uniquely contribute.  Sounds like beautiful interdependence to me!  Well, I would be remiss if I didn’t further comment on the question of human worth.  Where does it come from?  Is it all mindsets or social structures?  I can’t read this chapter without being influenced by the Bible.  At the end of the day, our self-worth exists evenbefore our contributions to others.  It’s deeper than that.  I believe we have worth because we were lovingly designed and created by God.  And amazingly, there’s nothing you can do to earn that worth.  It’s already been given to each and every person.    

“For we are God's workmanship, created in Christ Jesus to do good works, which God prepared in advance for us to do.”  (Ephesians 2:10, New International Version).        

If I make my contributions the measurement of my worth, my value is going to change day to day.  Even when I’m trying to love others and contribute to their lives, I can’t do it perfectly.  Thank God my value is NOT dependent upon me.  Because God first gave me worth, I can joyfully live as a contribution to others.       

Zander, R. S., & Zander, B. (2000). The art of possibility. Boston, Mass:
             Harvard Business School Press.
 
Week 2 - Reading Response
Saturday, October 8, 2011
1 COMMENT Manage Comments for this Entry
KEVIN MCLAIN
I agree with your assessment and summary of the idea presented in "The Art of Possibility" in regard to it's all invented.  I agree that it can sound a little like Positivism and like just "ignoring" the negative facts. However, I think it is a little different than that.   I do not necessarily think it means ignoring the facts or simply putting a positive spin on things, I think it goes deeper than that.  Like the story of the gentleman who was number 66 out of 68 (i think) but then Mr. Zander gave him an "A."  He was told he was two different things and he chose to believe he was the better of those two descriptions.  I think such a belief probably allowed him to realize his full potential.   I think too when we see the world as an "A," it changes the way the world rises to meet us.  I think that people will live up to the expectations we have of them.

Friday, October 7, 2011

Giving myself an "A"

(retreived from http://www.amazon.com/Possibility-Rosamund-Stone-Zander-Benjamin/dp/B001TI11ZA/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1318018498&sr=8-2 on 10/07/11)

In The Art of Possibility, Rosamund Stone Zander and Benjamin Zander take readers through a series of steps to re-imagine the world around them.  While the book started off as a form of pop-semantics lesson that seemed like diluted writings from Swiss linguist Ferdinand De Saussure, I really liked what it said about everything being invented but I felt like I had heard it all before.  The chapter I was most struck by was the part about giving the "A."  The several vignettes in this chapter provided illumination on a positive way to see the world for a critical person like myself.  If anyone has seen the recent film, "Our Idiot Brother," the idea of giving an "A" is illustrated by the central character, played by Paul Rudd.  He is explaining to another character the story of how he was arrested for selling marijuana to a uniformed police officer.  If you have not seen it, the scene in which he makes the transaction seems logical to the audience but just like if someone told the story in real life, you would assume they were an idiot.  Rather than embody that moniker, he simply shares the way he lives his life.  He says that he gives people the benefit of the doubt, that everyone has the best intentions, and when he approaches the world like that, more often than not, "people rise to the occasion."  That is the crux of giving everyone the "A."  It means, not selling people short, perhaps giving them more credit than they deserve and allowing them to rise to meet the challenge.  I think too often we are quick to fall into the measurement world of grading everyone rather than looking at the whole block of marble and seeing how we can chip away to make a more meaningful relationship.  It is certainly far easier than dismissing people outright.



Sunday, October 2, 2011

Copyright Criminals

I originally saw this on the PBS show "Independent Lens."  Its a fantastic documentary about how "copyright infringement is your best entertainment value."

http://www.hulu.com/watch/201358/copyright-criminals


(retrieved from http://www.negativland.com)

WIMBA




I think this weeks Wimba showed us the importance of making sure that all the technical aspects of our presentation are in place.  While the info we are presenting may be stellar and our platform for sharing it may be ideal, we are only as strong as our weakest link.  If we create presentations for our classes where the font is hard to see or videos that are impossible for our students to follow along, then the information shared is inconsequential because our students will tune out.

Week 1 - MAC 613 - Response to Fary




Fary,  Your post is really interesting and makes a lot of great points.  When I was in Panama, my experience was similar, there are street vendors all over selling bootlegged copies of the latest movies and music.   It is hard to see who benefits from these arrangements.

You also delineate a the most common myth that I have observed among educators.  Many believe that classroom use is acceptable because they heard somewhere that fair use covers education.  I think the videos this week gave a very clear view of how this is not true.  I think that it provides a challenge for educators to think of solutions while working within the copyright framework and following the law.

week 1 - post 2 - response to Rose




Rose,

When I was working as a Media Speicalist, I found the same thing that you described.  Most teachers assume that because they are using in the classroom that they fall under the "fair use" umbrella.  I found it interesting that "fair use is not a right but a defensible position."  I am not sure how you interpret that but it seems like what one person believes is fair use may not be viewed that way by its creator which lands the user in a grey area.  The way i recommended teachers avoid these grey areas is similar to what you described;  I always suggested that they create their own or use student created images.